Zum Hauptinhalt springenSkip to main content
Knowledge

Storage marketing: tolling, floor and profit share compared

If you do not run a battery on the markets yourself, you sign with a marketer. Three patterns keep coming back. The names of the firms do not matter here. What matters is who keeps the revenue and who keeps the risk.

Three patterns, no ranking

Tolling: you hand over capacity for a fixed fee. Market risk sits with the marketer. You trade possible upside for a plannable payment and you give up control.

A floor guarantees a lower bound and shares what sits above it. Downside is limited and part of the volatile revenue stays with you. Profit share has no floor. Revenue is split by a key, and you carry the market result.

What a percentage does not say

A percentage without a defined base is not a term. What matters is what the split refers to, who owes availability, who holds prequalification, how calls are settled and how the contract ends.

The same asset can sit below a fixed tolling fee in a quiet year and above it in a volatile one. Which pattern fits follows from the capital structure and from who wants to own the dispatch. I do not offer an industry formula.

Multi-use stays sequential

The contract does not change the physics. In each window a battery stays with one job: holding capacity, arbitrage or peak shaving. The marketer picks the window. Markets are not added.

Balancing products still require a 1 MW minimum bid under decision BK6-21-042 of 28 April 2022. Below that, a pool is needed. The marketer runs the pool, not me.

In the same context

No recommendation of a marketer and no revenue guarantee. The contract text prevails.

Common questions

Which model is best?

None in general. Tolling trades upside for a fixed fee, a floor shares above a bound, profit share splits the whole result. The fit depends on who can carry market risk.

Do you name marketers?

Not on this page. A ranking would be a comparison without criteria that can be checked. In a mandate, one draft contract can be read against the points above.

Do FCR, aFRR and arbitrage add up?

No. A battery serves one job per window. Mixed revenue is the mix across the windows of a year, not the sum of the separate markets.

Pooling storage: clusters and a virtual power plant for FCR, aFRR and arbitrage

A single battery serves one market per time window. A cluster can serve several, because different units take different windows. Prequalification and the minimum size remain the hurdle.

Minimum size and prequalification

FCR, aFRR and mFRR each require a 1 MW minimum bid under Bundesnetzagentur decision BK6-21-042 of 28 April 2022. A unit of 100 to 300 kW does not reach that alone. In a pool the threshold is made up of several units.

Prequalification with the transmission operator, proof of controllability and a marketing contract are what turn a pool into a bid. A direct marketer or the operator of a virtual power plant does the marketing. I do not.

Sequential, not stacked at the same time

A battery has one capacity window at a time. Charging, discharging and holding capacity exclude each other. Multi-use means the controller picks the window that pays most. The revenues are not added.

The cluster does not change that for a single unit. It changes that, in the same quarter-hour, another unit can take another window. The pool serves several markets while each battery stays with one.

What the mandate covers

I set out the structure: which units should join, which markets are realistic at the minimum size, which points the marketer’s contract must settle. Contract patterns and escrow belong there. The trading decision does not.

I accompany the choice of marketer. I do not take a commission on their revenue. Operation of the virtual power plant stays with the party licensed to run it.

Common questions

Why is one home battery not enough for balancing energy?

FCR, aFRR and mFRR each require a 1 MW minimum bid since decision BK6-21-042 of 28 April 2022. A 100 kW battery stays below that. A cluster reaches the threshold together.

Does the cluster serve several markets at once?

The pool can, because different units take different windows. Each battery stays with one market per window. The revenues are not added up.

Do you market the battery?

No. I advise. I am not a marketer and not a trader. Bids are placed by the direct marketer or the virtual-power-plant operator.

Is prequalification part of the mandate?

I sort the requirements and accompany the papers along the path the transmission operator describes. Technical prequalification of the asset stays with the people responsible for it.